by Cassie Mattia

Loveland, Ohio –¬†As Fall sports finally take flight another Loveland Tiger is being recognized for their outstanding athletic abilities! On July 30th, The Allstate Sugar Bowl announced that Loveland High School 2016 graduate and stand-out student-athlete, Drew Plitt, would be placed on the preseason Manning Award Watch List, which is the ONLY quarterback award that takes the recipient’s bowl performances into consideration before the winner is selected.

The Manning Award was created to honor the college football accomplishments of Archie, Peyton, and Eli Manning. The prestigious watch list includes 30 of the top quarterbacks in the United States going into the 2020 season. The winner will be chosen by national media and each of the Mannings after the bowls have concluded and will be announced after the College Football Playoff National Championship. Plitt is one of two MAC quarterbacks on the Manning Watch List this year.

In a near blizzard, Drew Plitt quarterbacked the Loveland Tigers to a 41 ‚Äď 23 win over Glenville at Canton’s Fawcett Stadium to win the Div II State Championship in 2013. The temperature was 28 degrees, the wind was 5-10 mph, and a steady snow kept plows busy clearing the Canton Fawcett Stadium yard lines throughout the game. Dec. 6, 2013.

Here is the list of the preseason 2020 Manning Watch List recipients:


 Name, Cl., School
 Cmp-Att  Pct.  Yards  TDs  INT  QBR  Rushing
 Jack Abraham, Jr., Southern Miss 275-405 .679 3,496 19 15 64.1  6 TDs
 Holton Ahlers, Jr., East Carolina 264-442 .597 3,387 21 10 57.8  359 yds, 6 TDs
 Ian Book, Sr., Notre Dame 240-399 .602 3,034 34 6 76.3  546 yds, 4 TDs
 Charlie Brewer, Sr., Baylor 251-389 .645 3,161 21 7 69.2  344 yds, 11 TDs
 Shane Buechele, Sr., SMU 307-490 .627 3,929 34 10 72.5  105 yds, 2 TDs
 Sean Clifford, Jr., Penn State 189-319 .592 2,654 23 7 76.8  402 yds, 5 TDs
 Jack Coan, Sr., Wisconsin 236-339 .696 2,727 18 5 82.0  4 TDs
 Dustin Crum, Sr., Kent State 216-312 .692 2,622 20 2 73.7  707 yds, 6 TDs
 Micale Cunningham, Jr., Louisville 112-179 .626 2,065 22 5 83.9  482 yds, 6 TDs
 Jayden Daniels, So., Arizona State 205-338 .607 2,943 17 2 64.4  355 yds, 3 TDs
 Sam Ehlinger, Sr., Texas 296-454 .652 3,663 32 10 77.6  663 yds, 7 TDs
 Justin Fields, Jr., Ohio State 238-354 .672 3,273 41 3 92.1  484 yds, 10 TDs
 Dillon Gabriel, So., UCF 236-398 .593 3,653 29 7 68.0  4 TDs
 Sam Howell, So., North Carolina 259-422 .614 3,641 38 7 72.3  NA
¬†Trey Lance, So., North Dakota State 192-287 .669 2,786 28 0 ‚ÄĒ ¬†1,100 yds, 14 TDs
 Trevor Lawrence, Jr., Clemson 268-407 .658 3,665 36 8 87.3  563 yds, 9 TDs
 Levi Lewis, Sr., Louisiana 243-378 .643 3,050 26 4 72.5  195 yds, 3 TDs
 Kellen Mond, Sr., Texas A&M 258-419 .616 2,897 20 9 73.5  500 yds, 8 TDs
 Tanner Morgan, Jr., Minnesota 210-318 .660 3,253 30 7 84.2  NA
 Bo Nix, So., Auburn 217-377 .576 2,542 16 6 63.8  313 yds, 7 TDs
 Drew Plitt, Sr., Ball State 238-370 .643 2,918 24 7 55.3  171 yds, 5 TDs
 Brock Purdy, Jr., Iowa State 312-475 .657 3,982 27 9 71.2  249 yds, 8 TDs
 Chris Reynolds, Jr., Charlotte 181-291 .622 2,564 22 11 67.3  767 yds, 6 TDs
 Chris Robison, Jr., FAU 291-471 .618 3,701 28 6 58.8  2 TDs
 Kedon Slovis, So., USC 282-392 .719 3,502 30 9 81.1  NA
 Zac Thomas, Sr., Appalachian State 225-359 .627 2,718 28 6 69.0  440 yds, 7 TDs
 Skylar Thompson, Sr. Kansas State 177-297 .596 2,315 12 5 70.2  405 yds, 11 TDs
 Dorian Thompson-Robinson, Jr., UCLA 216-362 .597 2,701 21 12 56.6  198 yds, 4 TDs
 Kyle Trask, Sr., Florida 237-354 .669 2,941 25 7 81.3  4 TDs
 Brady White, Sr., Memphis 269-420 .640 4,014 33 11 74.3  4 TDs


Archie Manning couldn’t express enough how excited he is to see what he thinks is a fantastic group of quarterbacks on the Watch List this year.

“Our Watch List is once again an exceptional group of candidates, but every year is a new year and we’ll be watching closely to add the best newcomers to the list after we get things rolling,” Manning said, “I’d also like to thank the Allstate Sugar Bowl for sponsoring this award; it means a lot to the entire Manning family that they include our name in recognizing the best quarterbacks in the country.”

Bryce, Julie, Marie, Steve, and Drew at Marie’s volleyball Senior night in 2019

Plitt, son of locals Steve and Julie, is very familiar with the art of playing collegiate sports as his father played baseball at Xavier, his mother played volleyball at Xavier, his brother Bryce also played baseball at Xavier, and his sister Marie plays volleyball at Ball State.

Before Plitt headed to Ball State himself to play football he was a top-notch student-athlete at Loveland High School. Plitt was a member of the National Honor Society all while earning multiple awards in both basketball and football. As a Junior Plitt was Team Captain, MVP, and First-Team All-Conference in basketball. In football, Plitt received All-Conference twice as well as Honorable Mention All-District as a Senior. Plitt helped lead the Loveland Tigers to a 2013 state title and still has the school record for career passing touchdowns (42).

In 2016, Plitt joined the Ball State Football Team as a fourth-string quarterback and made the decision to redshirt his freshman season. As Plitt worked his way up the roster in 2017 he received his first opportunity as a quarterback on October 26th against Toledo. Plitt ended up scoring a touchdown during the 3rd quarter giving him the confidence he needed to perform in his first collegiate start against Eastern Michigan. Plitt exceeded everyone’s expectations throwing a season-high of 169 yards and two touchdowns!

In Plitt’s 2018 season with Ball State, he became the 2nd string quarterback. During the season Plitt had the longest completion for the year coming in at 63 yards against Central Connecticut. Plitt had multiple successful games during the 2018 season earning him MAC West Offensive Player of the Week, the 2018 Ball State Ray Louthen Award (most improved player), and the MAC All-Academic Award.

Drew Plitt on the basketball court for the Loveland Tigers in 2015

During Plitt’s Junior year was when he really took on the leadership role at Ball State starting in all 12 games as the quarterback. Not only did Plitt help lead Ball State to be at the top of the MAC in scoring (34.8 points per game) and total offense (463 yards per game) he also led the MAC personally in touchdown passes (24), placed second in passing yards per game (243.2), and ranked fourth in total offense (257.4 yards per game). All of Plitt’s impressive 2019 stats earned him several accolades; the MAC’s West Offensive Player of the Week twice, the 2019 Ball State Co-Offensive Player of the Year, the MAC’s Scholar-Athlete of the Week, and the 2019 MAC All-Academic Award. After the completion of the 2019 Ball State Football Season Plitt gained the eighth-place spot on the Cardinals All-Time Passing Chart with 4,356 yards, he tied for “Most Touchdown Passes in One Game” with six touchdown passes against Fordham, and he also holds the fifth-place spot for “Most Passing Yards in a Single Season” with 2,918.

Drew Plitt dives into the end zone for a two-point conversion to tie the game at 28 with 17.5 seconds remaining in the 4th quarter against Zanesville in the 2013 State Div II semifinal. Loveland Magazine writer Ricky Mulvey described it this way, ‚ÄúThe Tigers had to make up for lost time, as the missed extra point forced the Tigers to go for two late in the game. That‚Äôs when the ‚ÄúHoly Plitt‚ÄĚ moment was born. The play was drawn up for Drew Plitt to run to the outside edge and into the end zone. The play appeared to be broken along with the Loveland Tigers when Plitt leaped into the air and across the goal line for the perfect two-point conversion. The game was knotted up at 28-28 and heading for overtime. Loveland eventually won 38-35 in double overtime.” (Photo by David Burig)


Ball State’s 2020-2021 Football Season is bound to be a phenomenal one as the team will have 16 starters returning. Last year the Cardinals battled for the MAC West Division Title winning some very important games against Northern Illinois and MAC Champions Miami. The Ball State coaching staff, team, and spectators have high hopes for Plitt’s Senior season and can only hope that Plitt will help lead them to a 2020 MAC Title!

Here at Loveland Magazine, we want to congratulate Drew Plitt on all his Ball State successes! We can’t wait to see how Plitt’s Senior season with the Cardinals turns out and we hope that he remains on the Manning Watch List through the entire season! If you would like to get information on how you can watch Plitt play football this year click here.

Be sure to follow the Ball State Cardinals Football Team for the latest news @BallStateSports,¬†@BallStateFB,¬†and¬†@BSUCoachNeu. You can also visit the Ball State Football Team’s webpage at

Stay tuned for the latest Sports 411 with me, Cassie Mattia!